Chapter 9 / cultural studies / Culture / France-USA / French / Make it Big in the USA / News

Parenting the American Parent

Children hold a special status in the United States.  They are given the responsibility of carrying the future of humankind. (“Children are our future.” Run for cover.) They are therefore either neglected or irremediably spoiled. There’s no in between. The super wealthy have other people take care of their kids. It’s the businesslike approach to parenthood. Those busy parents are also following the very fashionable British tradition of abandoning kids to Society (see the reason why British high-society trends apply to Americans in “Us, Them and the Others”). Successful upper middle class Americans, on the other hand, have become “professional” parents and take the matter as a second full-time job.

Burn this

When in the United States for the long haul and when becoming a parent here, you soon feel all sorts of peer pressure to behave like the other parents.  You are made to realize the “indignity” of the French parenting approach. With their children, the French practice a mix of moral “laissez faire” and strict intellectual discipline. Laissez-faire is mostly for the moral, political and religious matters (we believe that a child must form his or her own judgments through study and experience). Intellectual discipline is about questioning authority and the authorities, about examining facts and being critical of consensus. By contrast, the American way of raising a child consists of drilling in unquestionable truths about moral conduct, political beliefs and the meaning of life in general. That of course, doesn’t require intellectual honesty, just a healthy amount of propaganda laid thickly on a bed of gullibility.

Whenever French Dad sends his kid into the world with more interrogations than answers about what the world is and could eventually mean for his child (if it does bear any meaning at all), that raises a few American parents’ eyebrows. It’s also somewhat unfair to the French kid who finds himself or herself soon surrounded by boy scouts and mini cheerleaders who have everything figured out and explained by age twelve. Entertaining doubts and still searching for hidden truths is an uncomfortable position when you sit among people who are dead set on everything. I once saw a ten year-old girl fromTexas interviewed on TV about her religious beliefs. Her family happened to be practicing some kind of fundamentalist Catholicism. Asked what she thought of people who didn’t go to her church, she simply replied matter-of-factly, “They will burn in Hell.” That’s an extreme example but it still sums it up really well.

see Parenting the American Parent (2)

Excerpts from chapter 9 – The Long Haul in Make it Big in the USA, Jean-Pierre Ledauphin, 2012. Translation by Wallace B. Thompson

About these ads

4 thoughts on “Parenting the American Parent

  1. As an American young adult from an upper-tax bracket, I must say that my parents did not neglect or spoil me. They set clear boundaries and gave me and my brother autonomy in all other areas. I agree that children sometimes have too high of a social status in the United States, but the language you use is quite extreme and over the top.

    • Thanks for your thoughts, Anonymous. Please understand that I give here the translation of a book I didn’t myself write. To your point now, when one describes what appears to be a trend, one doesn’t account for everyone’s experience. It would also be interesting to know how old you are, as JP Ledauphin is explicitely referring to the current generation. His observations and comments might indeed not apply to your generation at all.

  2. Pingback: Me So Wanna Be Freshly Pressed « Make it Big in the USA Just because you are French

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s